Understanding the 10/13 Rule for Shell and Tube Heat Exchangers: A Guide for New Engineers

As you embark on your journey in the field of mechanical engineering, you'll come across various design principles and standards that will play a crucial role in your everyday tasks. One such concept that you'll encounter, especially if you're dealing with shell and tube heat exchangers (S&T Hex), is the "10/13 rule". Let's break it down!

What is the 10/13 Rule?

In simple terms, the 10/13 rule is a guideline for setting the design pressures in a shell and tube heat exchanger.

The Rule: The design pressure of the side with the lower pressure (be it the shell or the tube side) should be set to at least 10/13 of the design pressure of the side with the higher pressure.

Why is it important?
This rule ensures the safety and efficiency of the heat exchanger. By following this principle, we reduce the risk of mechanical damage, especially during unexpected incidents like a tube rupture.

Example: I was looking at a design data of a shell and tube heat exchanger and it is stated here that the shell side design pressure is 34 barg and tube side design pressure is 43barg.

In the event of a tube rupture, the shell of the heat exchanger will experience 43 barg.

Can it withstand the pressure?

Yes it can because it has been hydrotested at 1.3 × 34 barg = 44.2 barg.

Therefore, the shell design pressure must be 10/13 x the MAWP of Tubeside. In this case 10/13 × 43.7 = 33.6 barg (make it 34).

A Bit About ASME VIII Div 1:

Now, where does this rule originate, and why is it set at 10/13?

ASME (The American Society of Mechanical Engineers) is a globally recognized body that sets the industry standards for various equipment, including pressure vessels and heat exchangers. ASME Section VIII Division 1 (often abbreviated as ASME VIII Div 1) specifically deals with the rules for the construction of pressure vessels.

A few key things to know about ASME VIII Div 1 for our discussion:

1. Hydro Test: After fabricating a pressure vessel or a heat exchanger, a hydrostatic test is performed. This test checks the integrity of the equipment by filling it with water and applying pressure.

2. Test Pressure: ASME VIII Div 1 mandates that the test pressure should be at least 1.3 times the Maximum Allowable Working Pressure (MAWP). This is where the 10/13 value stems from. It ensures that even if the pressure on the lower side rises up to the higher side, it won't exceed the test pressure.

Why Does This Matter to You?

As a new mechanical engineer, understanding and applying standards like the 10/13 rule ensures the equipment you design or work on is both safe and efficient. Not only does it help prevent potential mechanical failures, but it also ensures that the equipment aligns with globally recognized safety standards.

Wrapping Up:

The world of mechanical engineering is vast and filled with numerous design principles, standards, and best practices. The 10/13 rule for heat exchangers is just one of them. Always remember, these standards are in place for a reason – to ensure safety, efficiency, and longevity. As you continue to learn and grow in your role, always prioritize understanding the 'why' behind these standards, as it'll serve as a strong foundation for your engineering career.
Part